Tactics in Intellectual Property Management That Medium-Sized Enterprises Can Emulate from Larger Corporations

Tactics in Intellectual Property Management That Medium-Sized Enterprises Can Emulate from Larger Corporations

Small businesses, or SMEs, can boost their intellectual property (IP) game and maximize their returns on IP investments through smart, strategic planning. Here's how they can emulate the IP strategies that larger companies use to make the most of their IP budgets, tailored to fit SMEs:

IP Strategy #1 - Leverage Expert Legal Guidance

Drafting patent applications takes precision. A poorly-organized or unclear patent application can result in claims that are too narrow or overly broad, leaving your IP vulnerable to competitor workarounds. Large companies hire established IP law firms or build in-house departments to ensure top-notch expertise, while SMEs may struggle with costs.

To overcome this, SMEs should:

1. Focus on hiring skilled patent attorneys with a strong track record, even if it requires a slightly higher investment.
2. Avoid having non-patent professionals write patent applications, as the specific language and structure required for patentable inventions can be complex and too much detail can be missed.
3. Prioritize drafting patent applications following a provisional application to provide time for a thorough review and adjustment.

IP Strategy #2 - Strive for Broad Coverage on Key Products

Large companies maintain extensive patent portfolios to provide multiple layers of protection for their key products. SMEs, on the other hand, often only pursue a few key patents, making each one critical to their success.

SMEs can adopt the following strategies:

1. Research and file multiple patents for different aspects of a product or service, such as components, software elements, or manufacturing methods.
2. Utilize broad claims that cover a wide range of variations of the patented product or process.
3. Monitor the competitive landscape to identify potential infringers and adopt a defensive strategy.

IP Strategy #3 - Optimize Patent Planning and Filing

Large companies make strategic decisions about where and when to file patents, while SMEs often lack this planning expertise. Consider these recommendations:

1. Develop a clear plan for which countries are essential for patent coverage based on market analysis, manufacturing locations, and potential partners or competitors.
2. Focus on filing patent applications in key countries and scale down applications for secondary markets to save costs.
3. Regularly review patent portfolios and readjust patent filing strategies as needed to ensure alignment with changing business goals.

IP Strategy #4 - Cautiously Monitor Competitors' Patents

Monitoring competitors' patents offers valuable insights into their future product offerings and market strategies. SMEs, however, may not have the resources to conduct thorough, ongoing monitoring.

1. Conduct periodic patent searches for competitive analysis to remain informed about competitors' potential moves.
2. Prioritize research on competitors' core product lines or areas of innovation to gain critical insights.

By applying these strategic adaptations, SMEs can bolster their intellectual property portfolios, level the playing field with larger companies, and strengthen their market presence.

Side note: For those interested in tracking the progress of their patent applications at the USPTO, the TIP tool offers statistics on the law firm and examiner handling your case. Access insights for your patent applications using the form below.

Sources:1. Ma, L., Zhou, B., & Zhu, H. (2019). Bridging Cognitive and Organization Gaps: The Role of Formal and Informal IP Factors in High-Tech SMEs' IP Management. Journal of Business & Economics Research, 17(5), 29-37.2. Caramanica, N. (2020). Protect Your Creations: Patents, Trademarks and Copyrights for Small Businesses. Harvard Business Review.3. Holley, E. (2021). 7 Key Elements of a Successful Small Business IP Strategy. Business News Daily.4. WIPO (n.d.). Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT). World Intellectual Property Organization.5. Lee, S., & Lee, S. (2017). Intellectual Property Strategy in Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises: Theoretical Part and Case Study. Korean Journal of Intellectual Property Law, 17(2), 243-264.

1. Small businesses can enhance their patent drafting by hiring skilled patent attorneys, even if it requires a slight investment, to ensure precision in patent applications.
2. Non-patent professionals should be avoided in the writing of patent applications due to the complex language and structure required for patentable inventions.
3. To give time for a thorough review and adjustment, it is suggested to prioritize drafting patent applications following a provisional application.
4. SMEs should research and file multiple patents for different aspects of a product or service to provide broader coverage, similar to larger companies.
5. Broad claims should be utilized in patent applications, covering a wide range of variations of the patented product or process.
6. It's recommended to monitor the competitive landscape for potential infringers and adopt a defensive strategy, even if an SME may not have the resources for ongoing monitoring.
7. Developing a clear plan for which countries are essential for patent coverage based on market analysis, manufacturing locations, and potential partners or competitors can optimize patent planning and filing in SMEs.
8. By focusing on filing patent applications in key countries and scaling down applications for secondary markets, SMEs can save costs without compromising essential patent coverage.
9. Regularly reviewing patent portfolios and readjusting patent filing strategies as needed can ensure alignment with changing business goals in SMEs, just like larger enterprises.

Read also: