Pondering a solution for preserving modest pensions: Would reducing the tax reduction threshold be beneficial?
Shedding Light on the Disappearing Deduction for Retirees
The government's proposal to remove the 10% tax deduction for retirees stirs up controversy as it might form a crucial part of the 2026 budget, with a target of raising 40 billion euros in savings. This move, projected to bring in 4.6 billion euros for the government, polarizes political groups such as LFI, LR, and RN.
© Freepik By Sabrina Guintini Published on
- Copy link Link copied
The 10% tax deduction on pensions mitigates the taxable income of older individuals, reaching a maximum deduction of 4,399 euros per tax household. Beyond 43,990 euros in income for one tax share, the deduction falls below 10%. To illustrate the impact, let's consider a retired single individual with a 20,000 euro yearly pension. If the deduction is removed, their taxable income increases from 18,000 to 20,000 euros, leading to an additional 220 euros in taxes each year for the 11% tax bracket. For a retired single person with an annual income of 40,000 euros, the increase would rise to 1,200 euros considering the 30% tax bracket.
The Fuss Over Slashing the Tax Deduction for Retirees ## "Retirees are being used as fall guys" cries CFDT Retraités
The removal of the tax deduction may cause a tax hike ranging from 10 euros to 860 euros, based on estimates by the French Observatory of Economic Conjuncture (OFCE). However, the least affluent 15% of households would be exempt. In the view of CFDT Retraités, Claude Wagner, "The CSG is calculated based on the reference tax income. Eliminating the deduction could move some into the higher bracket."
If the tax deduction for retirees vanishes, many LR deputies have announced that they would not vote in favor of the budget. This measure is perceived as unjust by unions and their online forum members, who feel cornered: "Retirees are being used as fall guys", underscores Claude Wagner. He proposes lowering the cap to 3,000 euros as a possible solution, "which would be a lesser evil", he concludes, "if it were reduced to **3,000 euros, for example, it would spare small pensions." In this scenario, the 10% tax deduction rate would disappear beyond an annual pension of 30,000 euros for one tax share.
>> Check out our tool - Compare the performance of retirement savings plans (PER) using our simulator At what age will you retire comfortably?
Circling around this article: taxation, retirement pensions, income tax
Behind the Scenes:
- Increased Burden: Lower income retirees may face an increased tax burden, potentially shifting them into a higher tax bracket if their income is chiefly derived from their pension. Resulting in reduced disposable income.
- Strain on Purchasing Power: The removal of the deduction might exacerbate the strain on the purchasing power of modest households, which may have limited financial resources to adapt to the increased costs.
- Inequality Worsening: The policy change could lead to disparities in income among retirees, with lower-income retirees suffering the most as they may lack financial strategies like savings or investments to offset the impact.
- Broader Impact: Potential social unrest among retirees, coupled with reduced consumer spending as they adjust to the decreasing incomes, could have broader social and economic consequences.
- The fiscal decrease, represented by the removal of the 10% tax deduction for retirees, may not only affect their personal-finance but also stimulate increased burden and reduced disposable income, particularly for retirees with modest annual pension income.
- This policy change could strain the purchasing power of low-income households, as they may lack the financial resources to adapt to the additional taxes, potentially causing a broader impact on the economy due to reduced consumer spending.
- If this proposal is implemented, the elimination of the tax deduction may exacerbate economic inequalities among retirees, with lower-income retirees experiencing the most profound impact as they may lack financial strategies like savings or investments to offset the effects.
- The controversy surrounding the removal of the tax deduction for retirees could lead to social unrest among retirees, potentially destabilizing the business sector as a result of decreased consumer spending, making retirees into unintentional scapegoats for attaining budget savings.
